Here’s the full text of the email from the infamous Dave (see previous post) regarding my recent coming out.
Hey Dave,
> By far…this is the best joke you have ever played on me and the rest
> of the gang. I’ve talked to everyone in our circle of friends, except
> Roy because Tom asked me not to…prolly because he’d tell me the truth?
> Appears they are all holding out too. So gratz…it’s airtight.
Sorry man, it’s not a joke. Tom asked you not to tell Roy because I hadn’t told Roy yet. He now knows as I told him the night before he left for Mississippi.
> However…if this is not a joke then I find this very disturbing…if
> not downright horrifying. Im not going to hold back a bit and consider
> this e-mail part of your uphill battle to become a woman.
Done. I consider having to deal with you and Shep part of the uphill battle. Some negative reaction is foreseeable in a general sense but it’s hard to predict from whom the negative reactions will come and how diplomatically or undiplomatically these negative reactions will be presented.
> Ok…as diplomaticly as I can put it…Will, your off your god damned
> rocker! This is fucking absolutely freaking nuts and you had better
> quit taking those fucking prozac pills because they are weakening your mind.
> You might think you are in control but you are being misled by faulty
> psychanalysis and open to the power of suggestion. Either way, you
> would never make the evaluation process. They would shit can you
> because you already take mind altering meds.
If you read the HBIGDA’s Standards of Care document (the document which guides medical and psychological practitioners in the treatment of individuals diagnosed with Gender Dysphoria) you’ll see that they do not screen individuals out based on their taking antidepressants. In fact, the document states clearly that:
“Hormonal treatment can often alleviate anxiety and depression in people without the use of additional psychotropic medications. Some individuals, however, need psychotropic medication prior to, or concurrent with, taking hormones or having surgery. The mental health professional is expected to make this assessment, and see that the appropriate psychotropic medications are offered to the patient.”
So, as you can see, antidepressants are often prescribed as part of the standards of care process where necessary although often the transition process itself alleviates the depression and anxiety associated with the disorder in the first place without the need for antidepressants. The upshot here is that as I transition I will quite likely be able to go off the Prozac (Zoloft actually).
I’ve attached the latest revision of the Standards of Care PDF document to this email in case you would like to read it in more detail.
Now, on to your two other points.
First, you said that Prozac muddles your mind and makes you susceptible to the power of suggestion. This is not listed in any side effects I’ve ever seen listed for SSRI class drugs. If you have reputable academic sources that justify your claims feel free to provide references and I’ll look them up.
Second, you said that my therapist is taking advantage of my weakened mental state to suggest that I need to transition to being a woman. This is clearly not the case since I’ve identified as a woman internally since I was (at least) four years old. Recently, I decided I needed to do something about it and so I sought out a therapist who is certified to practice under the HBIGDA’s standards of care. Since I sought her out for treatment regarding this condition it’s impossible that she could have used the power of suggestion to turn me on to this path.
> By what standards of masculinity do you compare yourself, where , if
> found wanting, you would choose to be the opposite gender? Aren’t you
> being too hard on yourself?
I don’t compare myself to standards of masculinity. Internally, my entire sense of myself is that I am female and that I’ve had to essentially wear a mask to fit in with society’s expectations. Indications from my childhood would be my persistent desire to cross dress since at least age four, my wondering when I would get my period, my wondering what kind of girl I’d grow up to be once the boy phase was over, fantasizing about my future life as a woman that Jesus would provide for me through some miracle to correct the obvious problem God made when he made me, etc… I have tons of these stories I can give you if you care to hear them but this has gone on my entire life and it has taken a lot of energy to go out into the world and pretend to be something I’m not…that is, a man. Believe it or not, my social anxiety and depression are at all time lows now that I can go out in public, be my generally girly self, and have fun. I could care less that others see me as effeminate or gay. I look forward to some of them accepting me as a woman.
> Geez, I thought you were a happy guy with a normal life …the house ,
> car, dog and picket fence to boot.Never ever would I think that
> underneath the surface there was turmoil that would turn my lifelong
> friend into something that the rest of us wouldnt recognize.
Happiness is a relative thing. If you’re gay and you have to pretend not to be your life is basically going to suck no matter what else you have going for you. Just imagine if you didn’t like girls and had to sneak around and get it on with dudes. Would you be very happy? I think not. Gender Identity is similar to Sexual Orientation in that if there is a mismatch in your makeup that society frowns upon you will have a hard time of it.
> You have to play the role of a woman for a year before they even
> consider you..now you know that right there will change
> everything…you are no longer going to be Will…you will be
> something completely different. You will be Will, learning how to
> become a woman in your mid-life. Not even you can see the outcome.
> Certainly you dont know if you will even be happy with yourself after having done the operation.
I am still going to be Will. In fact, I’ll be Will plus a lot of myself that I couldn’t share with anyone in the past. I think you’ll like the new Will++ a lot better, frankly, if you can get past your own (very understandable) discomfort with the concept.
There are no guarantees in life but based on long term post operative psychological analysis the odds are greatly in favor of my looking back on my decision very positively. I do not think I am making a mistake and I’m sure the process itself will weed me out if I do not conform to the model for which SRS is permitted. This is as it should be since I am in total agreement that those who would likely regret undergoing SRS should not be allowed to do so. That said, I don’t think they’ll weed me out as I am a very rational person and I know my history happens to match very closely that associated with those who are allowed to transition via SRS.
> You realize what you are playing with here? You could do something so
> irreversable that it could drive you to madness…even suicide! I am
> not joking here.
If I am wrong about this then you could well be right. Thankfully, trained psychologists (at least two of them) and a couple of medical doctors will all have to agree that this is the right thing for me to do before I get the necessary approvals to have SRS. If you are right and I am a bad candidate then that should come out in the wash.
> I have never questioned your manhood as a friend….never crossed my
> mind that you ever had a gender disorder until just a couple days ago.
> I think your mental faculties have taken a dive and you are not as in
> control as you think you are. Probably the meds you take now are
> forcing you to open up pandoras boxes exposing demons of the past that
> you have already dealt with.
Things that are repressed have a way of rearing their ugly head until they are dealt with. This is one of those things. My sex life and capability for intimacy were both deeply impaired by my keeping this secret repressed for decades. Rather than let it hurt my marriage I decided to do something about it which has already markedly improved my sex life and capability for intimacy. These are very good signs that I am on the right track.
> Oh, how could I forget…the question of your wife sticking by
> you….now that is totally bizzare. Usually something like this would
> drive a marriage apart. After all she did marry a man. So how is it
> she is now ok with another woman? Does she even know what she wants?
> This is not the time for anyone to be loving and supportive…this is
> the time for your friends and wife to drop you on your head for a wake up call!
I don’t think it’s bizarre although it is atypical. First of all, Liisa married me for many reasons only one of which was that I was a man. Obviously she wasn’t looking for a macho man in the first place since I certainly don’t fit that bill. She’s OK with my transitioning to being a woman because she has determined that although I will changing on the outside, who I am on the inside is what counts.
Most psychologists recommend that friends and relatives of transsexuals be loving and supportive despite your statements to the contrary. I recommend you take their advice and rethink your knee-jerk, gut reaction about how to handle the situation to whatever extent possible. The following two web-sites can provide you with some decent info on transexualism:
http://www.tsfaq.info/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transexualism
> If you told me you were born with female genitalia I could
> understand…but if you were born as a man then you are just trying to
> reverse mother nature for your own selfish ends.
There is a huge spectrum of male-ness and female-ness, even at the genetic level. On the far end of the masculine scale there are XYY chromosome males who often exhibit very primitive and violent behavior. On the other end of the spectrum you have XXX females who are extremely effeminate. Between these extremes there are all sorts of other conditions like Klinefelter’s syndrome, Turner syndrome, etc… that affect your gender expression and identity during early development and puberty.
There’s plenty of good scientific literature on all this if you care to do the research. Once I see an endocrinologist prior to beginning HRT (Hormone Replacement Therapy) I’ll have a better idea if I fall any of these known existing categories.
> First battle in life…know thyself. Accept who you are and move on.
> You think the grass will be any greener once you become a woman? Oh
> dear man…your lifelong troubles will only double at that point. Then
> your head just might pop because you will be pumped so full of female
> hormones a that point you wont be able to think straight.
I do know myself and I’ve made the decision to accept who I am and move on. In my case, I find that I have a female psychology and a male body so moving on is going to involved some changes as outlined above.
If you are under the impression that female hormones make you not think straight I think you need to do a little more research on the topic. That’s just not how that works.
> There will be more words on this. All of us are horrified…at least
> we worry for your welfare. Of course we all seem supportive and nice
> on the surface but I think you can imagine what our real feelings are.
Well, Brent expressed his reservations in a forthright manner that did not preclude his also being supportive and accepting of my ultimate decision. This is the tact that has the greatest chance of success, frankly.
If Tom and Bryan harbor reservations about my decision they have yet to voice them to me directly but I’m sure they will use similar tact if you are correct and they have such serious reservations.
> Don’t do it Will. Remeber Pet Cemetary? Don’t do it Will. Come back to
> the light and everything will be as it was.
This just don’t make no sense! :-P